Hamilton Beach 25360 Indoor Flavor Searing Grill – The Best?

Better Grills is supported by our readers. I sometimes earn a small fee when you click on the affiliate links.
Hamilton Beach 25360 Indoor Flavor Searing Grill review

Do you like to eat your food seared and grilled? If so then you must read our Hamilton Beach 25360 Indoor Flavor Searing Grill review.

It is one of the best that we found in the market. For a healthy and quick meal following a day’s work, you may not get a better option than this.

Through our review, you may be able to find out if this indoor electric grill is the one for your kind of cooking.

Read the rest of the Hamilton Beach 25360 review:

In A Hurry? Click Here To See The Price

Grill surface of the Hamilton Beach 25360

Hamilton beach 25360 grill plates

The effective surface of the Hamilton Beach flavor grill is 12 x 9 inches and that adds up to room enough for four burgers, and 3 T-bones just to give you an idea of how much you can cook on it at the same time.

There are two options for the lid

The lid is just a lid and does not contain a heating element. The two options are:

  • Stainless steel
  • With a window

This is just a personal choice and does not affect the grilling capacity or outcome of your cooking.

The Hamilton Beach searing grill with a lid viewing window gives you to watch what you are cooking without opening the lid. This will probably prevent the heat loss that you will always have by opening the lid of any grill. You have to decide if it is worth the extra money in your situation. The window model is a little higher priced.

Material of the grate

(Back to Top)
The grate is made of steel and covered with a non-stick coating to prevent your food from sticking. I could not find any problems with the grill plates. They are dishwasher-safe and very easy to remove.

Features of this grill

  • Temperature controller
  • Non stick
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Large drip tray
  • Searing option
  • Cost effective

Customer Reviews

“I just purchased and used my new Hamilton Beach indoor grill for the first time. It is not a skillet. If you read the description and look at the picture, you can clearly see that it is an indoor grill. A small version of what you would use outdoors to BBQ chicken with gas accept it is electric and is smaller to use inside. It has a grill plate for searing food and for making grill marks. I grilled chicken with BBQ sauce on it and it came out just great…

“My biggest concern was whether it would smoke a lot and set off our smoke alarm but it doesn’t. I have used it multiple times and it sits on my counter next to the stove. I leave the oven overhead fan set on low (which I do not even think I need to) and there’s no smoke filled air with the lid closed. I have not used it without the lid on so I can not speak to whether that would leave your home smokey….(read more what people write: Here)”

Better Grill Rating: 4.6

Pros & Cons


Finding positive news about the Hamilton grill was pretty easy, Here are the ones we found most.

  • Attractive
  • Real BBQ features
  • Easy to use
  • Sear marks
  • Easy to clean

I was not able to find too many cons of this Hamilton beach indoor electric grill. The occasional lemon that did not get hot or hot enough was about all I could find.

  • Power cord is short
  • Construction looks a little flimsy.
Find the price here

Summary of what we think about the Hamilton Beach 25360 Indoor Flavor Searing Grill

We can recommend this grill as a pretty good buy and this is based on an opinion we formed after reading a lot of the almost 600 reviews we found online in a short period of time.

Remember that this is a grill and not a sandwich or panini maker. Only the bottom plate is heated by the 1200 Watts heating element and the lid is just a lid and has no heating element. This does not mean you can not use it for sandwiches. You just have to flip them like on a flat grill or skillet you would use.

Hamilton beach indoor electric grill 25360

Although available in the version with or without the window we could not find any recommendation for the lid except that you can watch your meat cooking without opening the lid.

The only advantage is that the Hamilton beach searing grill with a viewing window will have less heat loss because that is what happens when you open the lid of course. This will make the grill have to cycle in and out less will give a more even heat in the cooking process.

The short power cord limits the possibility to place this indoor electric grill where ever you want it. With a length of about 2 feet, you are limited.

This grill is great to be used with skewers and makes some great kebabs that way. We recommend always using metal skewers since they can be used over and over again and it is a personal experience that the bamboo skewers always burn.

But maybe they work on this electric grill since there is no open flame. Use 8″ skewers to stay within the grill surface.

The temperature setting on the dial is in steps of 50 degrees ranging from 200 to 400 degrees. I read someone testing it and it heated up to even 450 degrees in his case.

More or less smoke is decided by the amount of fat in the meat you are grilling, just like on any outdoor grill. This is not a smokeless grill since they do not exist in my personal opinion. In the reviews we read most people mention that they see hardly any smoke unless they used real fat meat.

The reason I can come up with is that the grease runs of the nonstick plates pretty fast and does not have enough contact time with the grill to start smoking.

The large drip or grease pan like people call it got some nice remarks as being big enough. This has in many other grill reviews a con point. There are experienced users that line it with aluminum foil and they claim that they do not have to clean it or just at a minimum.

The taste of the meat is a question that is asked many times. Many wonder if the taste is the same as on a charcoal grill and there are as many opinions as websites about the subject. The overall opinion in the customer ratings I found is that the meat tastes great and many do not taste any difference with meat grilled on an outdoor gas or charcoal grill.

features and price of the Hamilton beach 25360 and 25361

If you like a larger grill area and a heating element in the lid also I recommend that you have a look at the Cuisinart GR-4N which also got some great ratings from many users.


For any serious grill use, we highly recommend the use of a digital thermometer. The best choice is to start with a pocket thermometer and maybe later use a digital probe thermometer so you do not have to open your indoor or even outdoor grill anymore. Both are also very good to use in the oven. Never have over or undercooked meat anymore.

Skewers are great to use on this grill and with the size of the grill surface, the best size to use and keep the handles cool are these metal skewers we found.

You can find a selection of skewers here!

Tips from real users

Tips we found from real users

  • Line the grease pan with aluminum foil for easy cleaning
  • Pre heat well before using if you like nice grill marks
  • Skewers for kebabs do work on this grill

For Hamilton Beach indoor grill reviews you can either click here or go to the menu.

Eddie van Aken

Eddie van Aken has run his own full-service restaurant for many years. Before that, he worked as a grill and buffet cook in some of the mainstream restaurants. With his experience using professional kitchen equipment, he is able to write expert reviews. You can read more about Eddie van Aken here.

Scroll to Top